Finally a retail beauty brand is embracing the trend called subcommerce: Sephora is launching a Birchbox-like subscription commerce service called Play!

In my daily work as futurist, journalist and speaker I am frequently shocked to see how lame corporate retail brands can be in tapping into actionable insights and trends that could help them to coin the business opportunities of the 21st century.

But over the years I have learned that old economy corporates struggle to adapt to new business models in time. While new entrants without legacy are agile, creative and disruptive.

So I decided to investigate what Sephora could accomplish with its new service, and where US consumers buy their beauty products today.

Brick-and-mortar Battle: Can Sephora Beat Birchbox?

Signing up gives for Sephora Play! gives consumers an assortment of 5 full-size beauty products for $10 per month. The service is accepting limited customer enrollment for now, but will be open nationwide in 2016.


Competitor Glossybox is priced at $21 a month. Birchbox offers its service for $10 a month.

However, Birchbox launched its service already in September 2010. So where was Sephora the last 5 years? Still in meeting rooms, discussion whether sub commerce would be a trend or a hype? How slow can you move if market data and competitor cases clearly show you: Run Forrest run…

Since 2010 Birchbox also collected $71.9 million in funding and used it to launch its brick-and-mortar ambitions. In fall 2013 Birchbox opened a pop-up store in New York’s Chelsea Market to test the retail concept, which became popular in no time.

In 2014 Birchbox opened its first permanent store in New York City’s SoHo. This retail store offers beauty freaks 2,000 products and about half of Birchbox’s roughly 500 brands.

In the back of its store, there’s a section called BYOB (Build Your Own Birchbox). Here consumers can choose 5 deluxe sample sizes for $15.

Sure thing is that Birchbox will open more retail stores in 2016, says Sarah Perez on TechCrunch.

My team of analysts estimates that Birchbox will have 2.3 million paid subscribers by the end of 2015. A total of $276.000.000 yearly revenues in boxes, in which its retail revenues are still excluded!

Before jumping into conclusions about who might win the battle between Sephora and Birchbox, there’s more to explore in beauty and digital commerce.

Where US Consumers Shop Online for Beauty Products

Online beauty shopping is massive in the US. And beyond ecommerce nearly 40% of the American health and beauty shoppers are signed-up for at least one subscription service to receive such products, according to AT Kearney.

Where US consumers shop online for personal care and beauty products?

Surprise, surprise? Jeff Bezos’ Amazon is the undisputed champion when it comes to online beauty shopping. 73% of US consumers buy their beauty stuff at Amazon, only 35% at Sephora. So digital commerce might have been a no brainer for quite some years.

And if we look to the right side of our planet. How many Asian consumers would buy their beauty products on Alibaba? The Asian markets offer tremendous opportunities for brands with ambitions. Also for beauty brands.

My Opinion

One thing is crystal clear. The ecommerce, mobile commerce and subscription commerce revenues in personal care and beauty will keep growing at massive pace.

Several corporate beauty brands have not been innovating at the speed of change and they have missed Noah’s ark by now. They will be too late to compete with the Amazon’s, Alibaba’s and Birchboxes of this world.

Sephora with 1,900 stores around the globe and a robust loyalty program, should be able to turn a significant amount of its current retail customers into their sub commerce service Play! In a few years’ time Sephora might even have more paid subs than Birchbox. If not, they waited far too long.

Now the last and most important question. How can old economy corporates that struggle to adapt to new business models in time ever compete with agile, new entrants without legacy?

My solution is called: the corporate garage or startup on request program. It blends corporate power with startup flexibility and creates the best of both worlds for corporate brands. Now they can finally compete with disruptive new players.

In 80% of these programs I work with the CIO. They have long term objectives, budget, not many specialized agencies and are willing to embrace innovation.

In 20% of the programs, I work with CMOs. The ones from traditional brands that often struggle to adapt to new business models in time. Now they need to compete with innovative, agile consumer technology companies, such as Google, Facebook, Spotify and Twitter. Or Birchbox.

CMOs at i.e. Sephora should understand much earlier that storytelling is changing, and unless brands know how to tell theirs in a quick, witty and purposeful way that is native to these new platforms, they will be left behind.

My opinion is clear and simple: Brands in all industries need to reinvent and refresh themselves. The only question is: Are you innovating at the speed of change?

Sephora, when looking at your pace of innovation, there’s one question that keeps popping into my head: Are your product innovations 5 years behind too? Are you a leader or a follower?

What About You?
What’s your point of view on subcommerce and corporate beauty brands? I would love to learn from your ideas in the comments below.

About the Author
In the spotlights, Igor Beuker is a professional public speaker and activist known for his foresight on trends and technologies that impact business, economy, and society. Behind the scenes, a social entrepreneur with 5 exits and angel investments in 24 social startups, an award-winning marketing strategist for brands like Amazon, L’Oréal, Nike and Unilever, and a new breed trendwatcher for Fortune 500s, WEF and the EU.

In the spotlights, Igor Beuker is a professional keynote speaker, emcee and publicist full of passion, power, and purpose. Behind the scenes, a serial entrepreneur with 5 exits and 24 angel investments, an award-winning marketing strategist for brands like Amazon, L’Oréal, Nike and Unilever, and a new breed trendwatcher for Fortune 500s.